With President Biden set to sign the recently negotiated budget deal, it is worth noting that despite the apocalyptic rhetoric, the United States economy actually remains remarkably strong – so much so that its economic strength actually creates its own concerns about the future.
Recent opinion polls in the United States indicate that a very large percentage of Americans – 69% in a recent CNN poll – believe that the United States “is headed in the wrong direction.” Predictably, Republicans are more skeptical about the future than Democrats – the CNN poll (and polling from The Guardian and Gallup) show Republicans to be much more bearish on the future of America by a margin of approximately 2:1. But neither are Democrats and Independents immune from disenchantment. A recent New York Times focus group of 11 “skeptical” voters indicated marked frustration with Biden’s decision to run for re-election, and cited his age, disinterest in governance and inability to articulate his views as reasons for their unhappiness. All expressed the belief that the United States was – wait for it – “headed in the wrong direction.”
Some of the reasoning for this belief seems to be tied to individual perceptions: inflation is up, Covid has left a mark on America’s public psyche, the tech industry continues to shed jobs, Congress is dysfunctional, the Fed continues to raise interest rates and, as Nobel Prize winner Paul Krugman points out, many economists continue to publicly assert that the US is teetering on the edge of an economic cliff – and have been for the past three years. Eventually, he notes, we’ll have that recession – but it does not look especially imminent at this point in time. It is worth noting that Googling “concerns over the direction of America” brings up articles from over 10 years ago – this is not a new topic.
The reality is that while inflation is higher than it was five years ago, it is actually much lower than it was a year ago. According to Krugman, “over the past six months [unemployment] was 3.3 percent, compared with 9.6 percent last June. The price of gasoline, a major political talking point last year, is now more or less normal compared with average earnings.” The recent jobs report – expected by many economists to finally show the beginnings of a recession – showed instead an additional 339,000 jobs added to the economy. And it’s not just the economy – America remains unmatched in its innovation (Chat GPT being just the latest game changing phenomenon), military power, and its system of alliances. The dollar remains the world’s reserve currency, and the country is now the world’s largest producer of energy. As a recent Foreign Affairs article noted, America’s unipolar moment has gone, but the nation remains in a class of its own in nearly all measures of global power – not as dominant as before, but also not as weak as Americans themselves are prone to fear. If the vexing fight over the debt limit showed anything, it may be that the real danger to America’s future is America’s own internal political strife – aided by a healthy dose of misperception.