Welcome to our world: The rest of the United States gets a taste of the West’s battles with climate-change fueled wildfires. The changes needed to climate change will alter where Americans live, and how they live there.
The recent wildfires in Canada have produced startlingly similar images to those afflicting California for the past three years (though due to early rains, last year’s wildfires in California were far less damaging to people and property than in previous years). News coverage of the fires were framed in somewhat apocalyptic terms, but if the images of orange-tinted skies demonstrated anything it was that what was once a largely west coast phenomenon is now continent wide.
The fires are a combination of poor forest management practices (over-attention to fire suppression over the past century) and climate change, which has dried out some places. At the same time, climate change has increased the frequency and power of wind and rain events in other parts of the US - leading to superstorms which can be equally, and perhaps more, dangerous than the wildfires. The trend is made more dangerous by the building of communities in areas vulnerable to fires and floods. While the best scientific data, including that from the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, a UN-associated body of scientific experts from around the world, indicates extremely strong causal links between climate change and highly damaging events such as hurricanes, floods, tornadoes and wildfires, the political will to respond has been very difficult to marshal. That seems to be changing – slowly. But even some conservatives now see the need to respond, however carefully. Conservative opinion has moved from outright denial to questioning the need to resort to “extreme” measures to control or roll back carbon emissions. Two Republican candidates for President, Mike Pence and Tim Scott, have acknowledged the reality of climate change, though Pence immediately qualified his statement by asserting that the planet “is not warming as dramatically as the radical environmentalists like to present.”
But if the political will has been slow to materialize, the economics of the situation are already forcing change, particularly in the all-important insurance industry. The well-respected journal Scientific American observed that climate change has “destabilized” the insurance industry by making major events impossible to predict with current modeling. In California, State Farm announced in May that it would stop accepting applications for all business and personal lines of property and casualty insurance due to “rapidly growing catastrophe exposure.” This follows a similar announcement by Allstate in November, 2022, which “paused” insurance coverage within the state. And it’s not just in California that insurance companies are hitting the pause button – Florida has been affected even more, with 16 home insurance companies pulling out of the state entirely, including Farmers and AIG. For those who remain, Florida’s insurance rates are up by 57% since 2015, by far the largest increase in any state. Another large storm could swamp the state-backed Citizens Insurance program, which keeps insurance costs manageable by underwriting coverage for Floridians unable to afford private insurance. Indeed, a large hurricane could make it impossible for insurance and state government to cover the damage without Federal assistance.
Insurers have traditionally relied upon long horizon historical modeling to determine risk over time, but in an age of mega-storms and mega-wildfires, such an approach is no longer viable. Coupled with slower but dangerous and destructive periods of heat, precipitation and drought, this means that, no matter what the political environment, Americans are going to have to factor the increasing costs of climate change into their home ownership – and consider moving away from particularly vulnerable areas. This could have enormous consequences for cities such as Phoenix, Houston, Las Vegas, Tampa Bay and Miami, all of which are particularly vulnerable to climate change. Indeed, in May, the city of Phoenix, the fastest growing metropolitan region in America, announced that it will prevent the building of new subdivisions, surely a harbinger of things to come.