On the surface, Secretary of State Antony Blinken’s trip to Beijing produced no tangible results, and in fact was initially presented by both China and critics of the Biden Administration as something of a dud. Expectations were low on both sides, and the meetings produced no breakthroughs on the trade war, no concessions by either side on Taiwan, Ukraine, or the purported Chinese intelligence facility in Cuba, no lifting of sanctions on Chinese officials (including Defense Minister Li Shangfu), no movement on human rights, and most unfortunately, no move to return to military to military contacts between the two sides. A number of Chinese (and conservative American) commentators asserted that by pushing so hard for the meeting - which was delayed by the Chinese spy balloon fiasco - the Biden Administration had placed the US in a position of weakness. And that might have seemed to have been borne out when Blinken arrived at the Beijing airport, where he was met by a mid-level diplomat from the Ministry of Foreign Affairs along with the US Ambassador, Nicholas Burns.
But from that point on, there was a perceptible change in tone. Optics are important, and meetings with Chinese leaders are almost always held at parity – President to President, Secretary of State to Minister of Foreign Affairs, mayor to mayor, etc. But besides 7 ½ hours of “candid and constructive” meetings between Blinken and his counterpart, Qin Gang, Blinken also met with Xi Jinping for 45 minutes. According to a Chinese source, Xi called on the US to “respect China and not harm China’s legitimate rights and interests,” but also stated that “China respects the interests of the US” and would not “challenge or replace” the United States. Xi’s own readout afterwards was cautiously positive. According to a State Department transcript, the Chinese president stated that “The two sides have also made progress and reached agreement on some specific issues. This is very good.” A small step – but it does open the door for more progress down the line by giving Chinese officials additional room for continued dialogue with their American counterparts. US Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen and Commerce Secretary Gina Raimondo are both tentatively scheduled to visit Beijing later in this year, and both may now have a bit more leeway in their visits.
There are still enormous hurdles to both sides returning to anything like the stable relationship they previously enjoyed, not least domestic pressures in both countries. Chinese commentators are sensitive to any perceived slight from the United States - and US public opinion is also very down on China. Speaker Pelosi’s visit to Taiwan, the off-course Chinese spy balloon, and even the Chinese base in Cuba all generate tremendous internal pressures on Chinese and American leaders to appear unyielding. In China’s case, there is also the perception that the US continues to pressure the world’s oldest civilization to adhere to a set of rules and a security order that it had no hand in creating – and indeed, to the Chinese, seems aimed squarely at preventing their emergence as an equal partner. But as Blinken himself stated, “[p]rogress is hard. It takes time, it takes more than one visit.” If the Secretary of State was able to arrest the slide in relations between the world’s largest economies, his visit was actually a success – a limited one, but a success all the same.