In October, 2007, I participated in the Annual Trans-Pacific Strategic Dialogue, a review of security concerns around the Pacific convened by the Japanese newspaper Asahi Shimbun and the Brookings Institution. The conference was held in San Francisco, and among the participants were legendary UC Berkeley professor of Asian studies Robert Scalapino.
As fate would have it, at the conclusion of the conference I was invited by Professor Scalapino to have a drink in the bar of the Palace Hotel bar with former Vice President Walter Mondale and former Senate Majority Leader Howard Baker. The three engaged in a lively discussion for nearly an hour, and I was content to simply listen to these giants of American policy. But gradually, the dialogue abated, and I was able to ask a question that I had always wanted to pose – but never dreamed that I would actually have the opportunity.
Turning to Senator Baker, I asked him the simple question: “Why did you do it? Why did you take on a sitting President from your own party?” – an act which clearly led to the downfall of President Richard Nixon in the Watergate scandal. I noted that both Mondale and Scalapino listened intently as well.
Baker seemed taken aback, despite my assumption that he must have been asked this question hundreds of times before. It seemed a very long time before he responded – and when he did, he simply said “Because it was the right thing to do.”
It was a simple answer, but a telling one. I remember watching Baker as a high school student traveling in Italy. In cafes and bars, the Watergate hearings were on full display. Barely visible on grainy, black and white television screens, with the dialogue overlaid by Italian commentators, Baker could be heard asking the now famous question “What did the President know, and when did he know it?” His question underscored Baker’s commitment to the truth and the Constitution. That I had watched the Watergate hearings in Italy was a reminder that, like it or not, the world observes America carefully.
The contrast with today is startling. The indictment of Donald Trump on charges related to the January 6 insurrection at the Capitol – even as he runs for President – is a stark reminder that democracy cannot be taken for granted. Very few Republican nominees for President have condemned Trump (only Chris Christie and Will Hurd have stated unequivocally that he should be held accountable, though Mike Pence seems to be moving in that direction). That inability by senior leaders in the party to condemn Trump’s actions has contributed mightily to Trump’s continuing strength in the polls – he has a commanding lead for the nomination, with approximately 70% of registered Republicans believing that Biden is an illegitimate President who stole the election.
The contrast between Baker’s moral courage then and today’s Republican leadership is stark, and the implications for democracy are profound. Baker was a committed, lifelong Republican – the first elected in Tennessee since Reconstruction. But he was an American patriot first - even at the cost of his own party’s electoral dominance. The example set by Howard Baker then should be one of interest to all Americans today.