The United States and China, the world’s two largest economies and two most powerful militaries, are both experiencing turbulence within their political and military leadership, which portends major problems down the line for each country and, potentially, for the entire global order.
In China, the sacking of Defense Minister General Li Shangfu represents the third time in three months that Party Secretary Xi Jinping has removed senior leaders from their roles in the foreign policy or military establishment. Foreign Minister Qin Gang was forced from office in July, allegedly for fathering a child out of wedlock when he was ambassador to the United States, and two senior commanders of the Rocket Force, which manages Beijing’s rapidly growing strategic missile force, were forced out in August. No reason for that move was cited, but speculation abounded, centered on corruption, disloyalty or the penetration of the Rocket Force by foreign agents. A former deputy commander also was reported to have recently died, increasing the speculation that Xi is intent on cleaning house at the top.
While not (yet) reaching the level of China’s leadership shakeup, the United States is facing its own governance problems. In the House, Republican Freedom Caucus members want to undo the deal that House Speaker Kevin McCarthy negotiated with Democrats and President Biden last year. If not resolved soon, the US Government will shut down all non-essential functions on or about October 1. The damage from the shutdown will be expensive (restarting the government always costs more money than keeping it funded), but perhaps greater longer term harm to the United States’ defense posture will come from Senator Tommy Tuberville (R-Alabama). Tuberville has blocked orderly promotions for the 300 most senior military commanders – including the chiefs of staff for the Army, the Chief of Naval Operations, and the Commandant of the Marine Force over his belief that the Pentagon should not reimburse serving military women who travel out of state for an abortion. While the Senate has now confirmed the appointments of the most senior leaders, hundreds of other appointments still languish, a situation Admiral Lisa Franchetti, acting Chief of Naval Operations, said could take years to remedy. Some key military officers, with useful skills for the private sector, may choose to retire.
In both China and the US, the leadership chaos points to deeper issues. For China, the removal of senior commanders and foreign policy officials appointed by Xi is both embarrassing and indicative of problems with managing key aspects of China’s military and foreign affairs. Xi is, however, in overall control and able to stabilize (or de-stabilize) the situation on his own. For the United States, the situation is more complex and potentially more dangerous over the long haul. American instability arrived with a vengeance with Donald Trump, and his unstable and chaotic four years of governance – including the hollowing out of the State Department and penchant for questioning the need for alliances, including those with NATO, South Korea and Japan. These relationships are the bedrock of American security. While President Biden has sought to stabilize American foreign and security policy, his task has been made much more difficult by Senator Tuberville and the House Freedom Caucus. The fact Trump could potentially return to the White House, with even fewer constraints than before, has to be a truly worrying prospect for America’s allies in Europe, North America and Asia – and heartening for Russia, China and Iran.