The humiliating end to Kevin McCarthy’s House speakership – brought about by a small group of mostly far right Republicans -- was not at all a unique event in the democratic West, though it was the first time it has happened in the United States. But the ramifications of McCarthy's departure could be profound. Just days before the vote in the House, Slovakia joined a long list of countries to have elected far-right – and frequently pro-Putin – leaders, joining Poland, Hungary, Turkey and Italy in this dubious club. In Italy, Georgia Meloni leads the Brothers of Italy party, which has a direct lineage to Mussolini’s Fascist government, while in Germany the Alternative für Deutschland is accused of essentially serving as a vehicle for neo-Nazism, which most Europeans had believed dead and buried. Even in countries with a long history of moderation - Sweden, Finland, and the Netherlands, for example - rightist parties have made advances in recent years.
There are a number of common themes among right wing Republicans in America and right wing parties in Europe. Among them – immigration and the “great replacement theory,”, economic resentment fueled by a fear at being left behind by wealthier and more knowledge-based regions (very powerful in former East Germany as well as much of the Republican caucus), fear of crime, toxic masculinity coupled with anger at women and minority groups, and a belief that governments are non-responsive and spending money overseas that should go to fixing problems at home. Taken together, these frustrations have metastasized into an aversion to compromise and a desire to blow up the system . This anger is further fueled by deliberate misinformation – some of it domestic, and some of it originating in authoritarian states such as Russia and China, both of whom see benefits in a dis-united West.
The United States has always had a strongly conservative and frequently isolationist wing of its body politic – from the Constitutional Convention and questions of how to address the issue of slavery, through conservative anger at the New Deal and interventions in both world wars (at least until Pearl Harbor). This latest iteration began with Nixon’s “Southern Strategy” designed to turn white Democrats against their own increasingly multiracial political party and the rise of the tea party. But the “burn the house down” mentality really arrived with Newt Gingrich’s speakership (though even Gingrich now seems worried about Republican dysfunctionality - he recently called on the party to oust Matt Gaetz, the primary archictect of Speaker McCarthy’s demise).
America’s allies and friends were already rattled by the Trump presidency, though President Biden’s commitment to a strong international presence moved these concerns to the backburner – concerning, but not an immediate problem. Republican dysfunctionality now imperils aid to Ukraine, however, bringing all those fears back to the forefront and undermining confidence in the United States as a reliable partner. For America, the tragedy will be the realization that trust – the confidence that keeps America at the center of the global economic and political system – is much harder to gain than it is to lose.