I used to think – up until little more than a week ago - that the great divide in the world was between liberal democracy represented by the US and its allies and authoritarianism, represented by China and Russia. In this view, Russia’s invasion of Ukraine was an outlier – dangerous, but containable so long as the US and its European and Asian allies remained firm in their commitments to supporting the global rules based order. But Hamas’ barbarous attacks on Israel along with Russia’s abhorrent behavior in Ukraine and Azerbaijan’s ethnic cleansing in Nagorno-Karabakh all lead me to believe that what we are seeing is really a growing divide between the world of global order and the world of global disorder. All of these attacks have targeted civilians, and all were undertaken with little regard for commonly accepted international norms. China’s support for Russia, despite its attacks on civilians and use of torture and Iran’s sponsorship of Hamas seem to reinforce the view that there are many leaders who do not mind a world devoid of rules – or at least, not the rules that the US and its allies have established. Unfortunately for those who want to maintain a stable and secure international environment, the internal dysfunctionality in the US political system – that is to say the House of Representatives – makes this moment even more perilous.
Looking back, we often think of the Cold War as a dangerous time. And it was: taken together, the USSR and the United States possessed nuclear arsenals capable of destroying the planet some 13 times over. But it was also, in retrospect, an extremely stable period (despite some near misses such as the Cuban Missile Crisis and the constant skirmishing in Asia and Africa between the two sides and their proxies). Both the US and Russia understood the limits of the system – the US did not intervene in Eastern Europe, and the Soviets did not directly enter the Korean or Vietnam wars (though Russian pilots did fight in North Korea and operate air defense systems in North Vietnam). Nor did Russian and American operatives kill each other, a small but significant means of ensuring stability.
For the most part, the “rules based order” of international institutions and conventions developed in the wake of World War II fared well over the course of the Cold War. Both Russia and the United states were founding members of the United Nations and its various subsidiary organizations, and a web of international agreements and organizations helped maintain global order (the International Monetary Fund, the World Bank, the nuclear weapons-limiting Non-Proliferation Treaty and SALT and START regimes, etc.). Both the US and USSR, along with most other countries in the world, agreed to uphold the UN Genocide Convention, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, and the Geneva Conventions, which protect non-combatants and soldiers who are no longer a threat (having surrendered or been wounded). These declarations and conventions have always been a product of hope rather than reality – a belief that a world with generally accepted rules was safer for everyone, including those on top today, but who might not be tomorrow. Despite the generally aspirational nature of these international agreements, the system was for the most part predictable and stable, heavily influenced by American economic power and military might. And though these conventions did not prevent human rights abuses, genocide, economic distress, or torture, they did provide guardrails to prevent them from spiraling into something much worse.
That system now appears badly damaged. US power was so overwhelming after the collapse of the USSR that no real challenge seemed likely, but American complacency and internal dysfunctionality along with strategic mistakes (such as the invasion of Iraq) have created a much more dangerous international environment. Non-state actors such as Hamas, ISIS and Hezbollah along with nations such as Russia, Azerbaijan and Iran seem to be working unapologetically towards the destruction of the global rules based order in favor of a Hobbesian state of nature – a world where there are limits on attacks on women, children, and economic and social infrastructure – a world of disorder.
While damaged, the system has not yet cracked up. Some international institutions such as NATO seem to have held up well, and the United Nations remains committed to maintaining the global order. But the United States – the linchpin of a rules based global order – has lost much of its internal cohesion and become dangerously dysfunctional. A large portion of the American electorate sees virtually no connection between global stability and their own well-being - and indeed is tending towards isolationism. Yet if nothing else, the attacks of 9/11, Covid, increasing impacts from climate change and the mass migration of economic and environmental refugees should remind us that we cannot wall ourselves from the rest of the world. Like it or not, their problems are ours – and an active and engaged America in support of the rules based order makes the world much safer in the long run – not least for Americans.