News Roundup

Sources (2) ↓

On October 27, I testified (along with GlobalSF Executive Director) in front of the chairs of two California State Assembly committees, the Committee on Finance and the Committee on Jobs, Economic Development and the Economy. The focus was how to increase the economic viability of inland California, which has not kept pace with the State's overall remarkable economic performance, though agricultural products are by volume the state's most valuable exports. Three countries - Japan, Denmark and Israel - could serve as potential models for California's inland areas. Japan, with an aging population, was the first "test case" - and so receives the lion's share of time.

Statement on Inland California Project

California State Assembly Hearing

Assembly Committee on Finance, and Committee on Jobs, Economic Development and the Economy

October 27, 2023

· As State Assembly legislators, you know better than anyone that in many ways, there are two Californias – the generally prosperous innovation and knowledge-based economies of the coastal regions, and the less-prosperous and mostly agricultural inland counties, particularly in the Central Valley and Inland Empire.

· The data from the US census bears this out: In the San Joaquin Valley family incomes are far below the coastal average. Median family incomes in Tehama county are $42,369, in Tulare county the median family income is $45,296 and in Merced county $53,992. These counties median family income levels are closer to Mississippi ($42,716), West Virginia ($51,248), and Alabama ($53,913), while Alameda County – not the wealthiest in California – has an annual family income of $90,822.

o In “A Portrait of California” by the Social Science Research Council, notes that of the more than 30 percent of the California population classified as either “struggling” or “disenfranchised,” the overwhelming majority live in the state’s interior.

o And importantly, houses are far less expensive in Mississippi, Alabama and West Virginia.

o The difference between the coastal and inland regions is so dire that in 2010 The Economist magazine warned that Inland California was in danger of becoming “The Appalachia of the West.”

· The question then is “what do about it?” – which is where the Inland California Project comes in. The Inland California Project is an initiative of four University of California campuses – Berkeley, Merced, Riverside and Davis, with the support of various think tanks, NGOs, the Central Valley Community Foundation and the Carnegie Foundation. At the state level, Go-Biz and the California Dept of Food and Agriculture have also been involved.

· The core concept is that three countries – Japan, Israel and Denmark – have confronted issues in their rural agricultural areas similar to those confronting California, and each has adopted systems and policies designed to arrest decline and encourage growth in their rural areas.

· We set out to tease out which of these policies actually could potentially be adopted in California with some likelihood of success.

· The first test case we adopted was Japan.

o In June, at UC Merced, Dr. Kenji Kushida from the Carnegie Foundation gave a presentation focused on how Japan is coping with an aging workforce, and then identified a number of areas where California might consider adopting policies and incentives designed to encourage innovation and upskill the workforce to “do more with less.”

· Among Kenji’s findings:

o Japan has adopted three models for dealing with its demographic challenges: Replacement (the use of machines to replace humans); augmentation (use of machines to enhance human productivity), and repurposing (use of machines previously designed for another purpose).

o The Japanese government has created incentives to innovate as well as policies designed to force change.

· A key area for Japan, which almost certainly has potential application for California is the category of “upskilling”- that is to say augmentation of the workforce, or the ability to enhance worker productivity through innovation.

o New technologies – including AI and the integration of drones with machinery – can enhance worker productivity, and if done right can do so without replacing workers so much as making them more productive and – not to be underestimated - happier in their jobs.

§ (Construction and transportation machinery are especially adaptable in this regard.)

· However, Kenji also noted that there are some significant differences between Japan and California.

o Civic and physical infrastructure – prevalent in Japan -- is frequently lacking in rural California

o The Japanese government – and the population -- are fully behind use of innovation and automation. Not the case in California, which has multiple political challenges. In the past, Japanese government policy was highly restrictive, but that has changed.

o The healthcare safety net is well developed in Japan, including in rural areas. Telehealth is already heavily utilized to support physical and mental health for the rural population – keeping them healthy and productive even into their 80s.

o Japan has broadband internet readily available – not always the case in California.

· He noted how we frame these issues is vital for California.

· The next discussion will be on Denmark, which like California is an advanced agricultural economy.

o Denmark’s “triple helix (business, government and academia) is a good approach (and will be covered in the next roundtable at the end of February). In contrast with many countries, in California business and government frequently do not collaborate effectively and frequently do not speak the same language.

· With Israel, slated for May or June, the focus will be on moving ever further up the value chain while at the same time accounting for water scarcity – though at the moment this seems like a longer term need given how much water the state has gotten and expects to get.

· We hope to wrap this initiative up in fall of next year with a conference in Sacramento which will include state policymakers from both the executive and legislative branches. We are also exploring the possibility of a book which will delve a bit further into these areas of mutual interest.

One final thought: while investment in California's regions remains a good bet, the biggest "bang for the buck" will come from the State's inland areas, where costs are lower and the returns on investment potentially even higher. But it will require an ongoing commitment by the state to make this happen.

Thank you for your time!

Sources

Links go to the original publishers. Some require a subscription.

  1. [1] United States Census Bureau data () Read article data.census.gov
  2. [2] The Appalachia of the West, The Economist, Jan 21, 2010, Read article economist.com

All newsletters