“Planet Earth is big enough for two”

Sources (18) ↓

In a speech in front of President Eisenhower at the White House in 1954, Winston Churchill stated that “to jaw-jaw is always better than to war-war.” Last week’s meeting at the margins of the APEC conference in San Francisco was a classic application of Churchill’s phrase. China – US relations have been tense over the past year, with continuing strategic and economic rivalry as a backdrop to concerns that conflict could result either purposely (a Chinese attack on Taiwan) or accidently (a collision between Chinese and American or allied ships or aircraft that escalates into something neither side wants). The negative feedback loop of American rhetoric on the return of a new Cold War and Chinese rhetoric that “The East is rising and the West is declining” has only made matters worse.

With relations at low ebb, expectations for the meeting between Chinese President Xi Jinping and President Biden at the margins of the San Francisco APEC conference were modest, so exceeding the low bar was an easy task. But there were real elements of substance in the discussions, and importantly, they set the stage for further dialogue over time. Both sides had a laundry list of concerns, and both sides had good reason to find areas of common ground.

For President Biden, the laundry list arguably started with simply not letting things get worse – heading into a tough election year with a deeply divided electorate, two foreign policy crises (Gaza and Ukraine) on his plate and a restive House riven by internal Republican divisions, the chance for a reset of the relationship with China was an opportunity not to be missed. Much of the American wish list therefore centered on lowering the temperature in the Asia Pacific through restoration of direct military to military contacts between the two countries, both at the senior leadership level (Pentagon to Chinese Ministry of Defense) and also between military commanders in the Pacific. They also agreed to resume defense and maritime policy coordination meetings, which while not high-profile discussions, provide an opportunity for both sides to get to know the other in a non-crisis setting – which can actually be important in a crisis. Emphasizing competition over conflict, Biden also took the opportunity to gain some Chinese promises of help on illicit drugs, and agreements to work together on climate change, and urged the Chinese to play a constructive role in easing global tensions overall.

For his part, President Xi also had reasons to work more constructively with the United States. The meeting helps Xi present a domestic image as a world statesman at a time when his management of China’s security and foreign policy apparatus has been marked by turnovers at the most senior levels (both foreign and defense ministers have disappeared from public view and then been replaced). Furthermore, with the Chinese economy slowing, he needs to focus on domestic affairs. Contributing to Xi’s economic problems are American sanctions on technology transfers, chips and high end manufacturing, and the Biden Administration’s efforts to shift critical supply chains away from China and towards American friends and allies (“Friend-shoring”). Along with tariffs, these measures are now having a noticeably negative impact on the Chinese economy. Easing US sanctions and encouraging American business to invest in China would be important steps to ameliorating Xi’s foreign and domestic challenges.

While the tone of both sides was upbeat in the aftermath of the discussions, there are a number of elephants in the room, Taiwan, first and foremost, which one Chinese official described as the “biggest, most dangerous issue” in US-China relations. China believes that the Biden administration has encouraged Taiwanese moves towards political independence from the PRC, while the Americans fear that China really will invade at some future time – the island is central to Xi’s assertion of the “great national rejuvenation of the Chinese nation.” Neither side got exactly what they wanted – Biden did not agree to cease arms sales to Taiwan and asserted that the island must make its own electoral choices, while Xi reminded Biden that reunification is still one of his top national priorities. According to one observer, “…President Biden [stated] that the longstanding position of the United States was a determination to maintain peace and stability, that we believed in the status quo, and that we asked the Chinese to respect the electoral process in Taiwan.” But the official continued that Xi responded by saying: “Look, peace is all well and good, but at some point we need to move towards resolution more generally.”

Though President Xi stated that China is “ready to become a partner and friend” to the United States at an APEC business dinner, there are many structural issues between the two countries that point to increased rivalry over time – economic competition is intense, and American officials are busy shoring up relationships with countries in the Indo-Pacific, which China sees as an effort to contain its ambitions. For its part, China has attempted to fence off much of the South China Sea, which the US rejects, and continues to support Russia's war of aggression in Ukraine. Perhaps most dangerously, Xi seems to believe that the US is in decline as a great power, potentially unable or unwilling to uphold its international commitments. Despite these concerns, the worst that can be said of the Xi-Biden meeting is that it stopped – at least for the moment – the downward slide in relations between the world’s two largest economies and the region’s two largest military powers and perhaps set the stage for a rapprochement. As President Xi put it, “Planet earth is big enough for two.”

Sources

Links go to the original publishers. Some require a subscription.

  1. Readout of President Joe Biden’s meeting with President Xi Jinping of The People’s Republic of China (The White House) Read article whitehouse.gov
  2. Xi stresses role of people in US – China relations (Xinhua News) Read article english.news.cn
  3. Summit meeting between Xi, Biden sees candid talks (Cao Desheng/China Daily) Read article chinadaily.com.cn
  4. China praises warm Biden Xi meeting in marked change of tone (Amy Hawkins/The Guardian) Read article theguardian.com
  5. Biden-Xi dial back rancor in summit to stabilize ties (Andrew Restuccia, Lingling Wei and Charles Hutzler/Wall Street Journal) Read article wsj.com
  6. Xi-Biden talks seen as putting rocky US-China relations back on course, though differences remain (Christopher Bodeen/AP) Read article apnews.com
  7. Takeaways from the Xi-Biden Summit, where low expectations were met (Steven Collinson/CNN) Read article edition.cnn.com
  8. Meeting low expectations: Analyzing President Biden’s summit with Xi Jinping (David Sacks/Council on Foreign Relations) Read article cfr.org
  9. What China’s Xi gained from his Biden meeting (Michael Martina, Trevor Hunnicutt and Greg Torode/Reuters) Read article reuters.com
  10. Pandas, fentanyl and Taiwan: Takeaways from Biden’s long-awaited meeting with Xi (Chris Megerian and Zeke J Miller/AP News) Read article apnews.com
  11. Xi signals marked shift in tone for China with US, but with Biden’s off the cuff “dictator” remark, can it last? (Simone McCarthy/CNN) Read article cnn.com
  12. US business executives get no reassurance from Xi on tougher business environment (Lingling Wei and Charles Hutzler/Wall Street Journal) Read article wsj.com
  13. Biden needs to convince America that dialogue with China is in its interest (Jente Althuis and Leslie Vinjamuri/Chatham House) Read article chathamhouse.org
  14. Niall Fergusson and Condoleeza Rice on the new Cold War (The Economist) Read article economist.com
  15. Behind public assurances, Xi has spread grim views on the US (Chris Buckley/NYTimes) Read article nytimes.com
  16. Joe Biden hails progress in talks with Xi Jinping but Taiwan is still the sticking point (Julian Border/The Guardian) Read article theguardian.com
  17. The East is rising: Xi maps out China’s post-Covid ascent (Chris Buckley/NYTimes) Read article nytimes.com
  18. What Xi Jinping’s speech means for Taiwan (Xi’s speech linking Taiwan with China’s great rejuvenation) – (David Sacks/Council on Foreign Relations) Read article cfr.org

All newsletters