Venezuela, Greenland and Trump’s National Security Strategy says more about American weakness than making America great

Sources (24) ↓

“Nobody’s going to fight the United States militarily over the future of Greenland…We live in a world, in the real world … that is governed by strength, that is governed by force, that is governed by power. These are the iron laws of the world since the beginning of time.” Stephen Miller to Jake Tapper, January 5, 2026

“Even a modestly intelligent ninth grader knows that to invade Greenland would be weapons-grade stupid.”

Sen. John Kennedy (R-LA), January 7, 2026

Just ten years ago, White House Deputy Chief of Staff Stephen Miller’s assertion of the American right to take Greenland from Denmark would have seemed like a White House official going rogue, and been quickly squashed with an apology to Denmark and an affirmation of America's belief in the importance of its alliances. Unfortunately, these comments are no longer surprising because they follow a consistent pattern in the second Trump administration. Indeed, the intellectual framework for such comments emerged in December, 2025, with the release of the Trump Administration’s National Security Strategy 2025 (NSS 2025). Less an actual strategy than an assertion of the Administration’s principles, the Trump National Security Strategy represents a momentous break with the past 80 years of American foreign and security policy, including Trump's own 2017 national security strategy.

Miller's "might makes right" assertion – along with President Trump’s statement to the New York TImes that “I don’t need international law” -- aligns directly with the National Security Strategy's rejection of promoting democracy abroad and its emphasis on the pragmatic pursuit of American power and prosperity without regard to international norms or institutions. Far from being an outlier, Miller and Trump’s statements build on the Trump national security doctrine, which provides the philosophical justification for the administration's actions in Venezuela and interest in taking over Greenland.

Previous administrations’ security strategies – including Biden's and even Trump’s -- focused heavily on advancing US interests by promoting a free, open, and secure world, with Biden’s also addressing shared global challenges like climate change and economic opportunity. Both Biden and the 2017 Trump strategy saw the United States as an indispensable cornerstone for a global system underpinned by shared American-centered values, including democracy, the rule of law, and transnational institutions such as the United Nations. For example the 2017 Trump document included support for “fundamental individual liberties beginning with the freedoms of religion, speech, the press, and assembly.” Both Biden and Trump 2017 saw China and Russia as America’s greatest security challenges, expressing worry over their desire to "shape a world antithetical to U.S. values and interests.” China was framed as a long-term "pacing challenge" while Russia was characterized as an "acute threat." By contrast, and remarkably, the new NSS 2025 does not expressly reference major power competition at all (though it does go into detail about the threat of "internal subversion" - that is to say, threats from inside the United States).

What replaces the earlier emphasis on human rights, the rule of law and democracy is a foreign policy based on the principles of power and a narrow vision of American self-interest, including “Trump Corollary” to the 1823 Monroe Doctrine (“We will deny non-Hemispheric competitors the ability to position forces or other threatening capabilities, or to own or control strategically vital assets, in our Hemisphere.”). The promotion of democracy abroad – once a bedrock of American foreign policy – is not mentioned at all, and indeed the document explicitly rejects pressuring other countries, such as the Gulf monarchies, on democratic reforms. In essence, the strategy replaces liberal democratic values with transactional relationships based purely on economic and security interests and the preservation of “American cultural values” through “Judeo-Christian” values and identity. Both in comments and actions, Trump's new foreign policy seems a throwback to 19th century great power competition.

But there is something more here – something unintended by Miller and the authors of the Trump national security policy. Simply put, as Anne Applebaum and other security analysts note, both are admissions of American weakness, not of strength. As enunciated in NSS 2025, Trump’s administration gives up a global order designed (largely) by Americans, and which (largely) benefitted American interests for the much narrower scope of primacy in the Western Hemisphere and the ability to act without regard to international norms or institutions. That is a bad bargain. Europe remains central to American defense and security, which even NSS 2025 acknowledges. Threats and tariffs directed at NATO allies - particularly Denmark and Canada – vastly diminish America’s power and attractiveness as a partner. The same is true in Asia. While NSS 2025 acknowledges that the Indo-Pacific region will remain among the “key economic and geopolitical battlegrounds” and that “to thrive at home, we must successfully compete there,” its actions on tariffs and bullying of allies severely undermines America’s appeal as a reliable partner – a point already being made by Chinese diplomats and government and media outlets. And what the strategy omits is that the Indo-Pacific is also important because the “rules of the road,” particularly those governing passage and freedoms of the seas, are being hotly contested there. Failing to work with American friends and allies to shape these rules cedes the high ground to China and undermines U.S. national interests. Asian nations have used the rules based order to work with the US as a counterweight to China. Without those rules, and with America appearing fickle and unreliable, they are likely to gravitate more towards China out of necessary self-interest. And finally, in Latin America, Trump’s resurrection of the Monroe Doctrine, his abduction of Venezuelan President Maduro, and his comments that the US will “run” Venezuela (and its oil industry) simply reminds most Central and South American countries of nearly 200 years of “Yanqui imperialism” and American support for anti-democratic regimes with terrible human rights records.

What the Trump administration is doing on an ongoing basis is undermining America’s long-term security for short term gains. Perhaps the best conclusion here is one offered by the Brookings Institution’s Emily Harding: “It is worthwhile to pay appropriate short-term costs for the long-term gain of Pax Americana. Those costs are investments—in security, open trade, democracy, and alliances. Losing sight of these underpinnings of global peace will not make America First; it will make America weak.”

Sources

Links go to the original publishers. Some require a subscription.

  1. National Security Strategy of the United States of America 2025 (The White House) Read article whitehouse.gov
  2. National Security Strategy of the United States of America (The White House, December 2017) Read article trumpwhitehouse.archives.gov
  3. Fact Sheet: The Biden-Harris Administration’s National Security Strategy (National Archives Oct 12, 2022) Read article bidenwhitehouse.archives.gov
  4. Unpacking a Trump twist of the national security strategy (Council on Foreign Relations Expert Brief) Read article cfr.org
  5. The national security strategy: The good, the not so great, and the alarm bells (Emily Harding/Center for Strategic and International Studies) Read article csis.org
  6. Breaking down Trump’s 2025 National Security Strategy (Brookings Institution panel of experts) Read article brookings.edu
  7. Trump lays out a vision of the presidency restrained by only "my own morality" (David Sanger, Tyler Page, Katie Rogers and Zolan Kanno-Youngs/NYTimes) Read article nytimes.com
  8. Stephen Miller offers a strongman’s view of the world (Katie Rogers/NYTImes) Read article nytimes.com
  9. Trump escalates aggressive posture on Greenland (Jared Gans/The Hill) Read article thehill.com
  10. Stephen Miller escalates Trump’s threats for the US to take over Greenland and defends Venezuela raid in fiery CNN appearance (Josh Marcus/The Independent) Read article independent.co.uk
  11. What Trump’s 2025 National Security strategy reveals about the future of US foreign policy (Andrew W Reddie/Goldman School of Public Policy) Read article gspp.berkeley.edu
  12. A national security strategy that isn't (Bob Rae/Policy: Canadian Politics and Public Policy) Read article policymagazine.ca
  13. US to “run” Venezuela after Maduro captured, says Trump: Early analysis from Chatham House experts (Christopher Sabatini, Laurel Rapp, Bronwyn Maddox, Orysia Lutseyevich/Chatham House) Read article chathamhouse.org
  14. What did Trump just do in Venezuela? (Anne Applebaum/David Frum Show) Read article youtube.com
  15. Trump’s anti-globalism looks a lot like old school Yankee imperialism (Ishan Tharoor/Washington Post) Read article washingtonpost.com
  16. “Voodoo Rituals” and Banana Wars: US military action in Latin America (Helene Cooper/NYTimes) Read article nytimes.com
  17. Trump is teaching the world to fear America (Fareed Zakaria/Washington Post) Read article washingtonpost.com
  18. Senate Republican: Greenland invasion would be “weapons-grade stupid” (Alexander Bolton/The Hill) Read article thehill.com
  19. Trump’s attack on Venezuela could change the world: Here’s how (roundup of various perspectives from across the spectrum/Politico) Read article politico.com
  20. Europe and the rest of the world try to come to terms with Trump the imperialist (Steven Erlanger/NYTImes) Read article nytimes.com
  21. The many risks to Donald Trump’s plan to “run” Venezuela (The Economist) Read article economist.com
  22. Buy Greenland? Take it? Why? An old pact already gives Trump a free hand (Jeffrey Gettleman, Amelia Nierenberg and Maya Tekeli/NYTImes) Read article nytimes.com
  23. What Maduro’s capture says about Trump (William A Galston/Wall Street Journal) Link not available online
  24. The oil tanker drama is a spectacular reminder that the US doesn’t play by the rules (Mary Dejevsky/The Independent (UK) Read article independent.co.uk

All newsletters