“So, other presidents have spent…trillions and trillions of dollars on NATO and gotten absolutely nothing in return. We've never asked for anything. It's always a one-way street….But now what I'm asking for is a piece of ice, cold and poorly located that can play a vital role in world peace and world protection. It's a very small ask compared to what we have given them [NATO] for many, many decades. But the problem with NATO is that, we'll be there for them 100%, but I'm not sure that they will be there for us.” (Special Address by President Donald J. Trump, at Davos, January 21, 2026)
"The old [rules based] order is not coming back. We should not mourn it. Nostalgia is not a strategy. But from the fracture, we can build something better, stronger and more just." (Special address by Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney at Davos, January 20, 2026)
President Trump and Canadian Prime Minister Carney spoke on consecutive days at the World Economic Forum annual conference in Davos, Switzerland. Despite sharing a continent and a 3000 mile border, the speeches could not have been more different in both tone and substance.
President Trump’s speech was a shambolic litany of grievances against some of America’s closest allies, including of course Canada, Denmark and NATO. His obsession with taking control of Greenland was an underlying constant, delivered, as noted by Time magazine’s Philip Elliot, “as if it were a cutting-room-floor discard from Goodfellas” (Martin Scorsese’s 1990 gangster film): “We want a piece of ice for world protection, and they won’t give it. You can say yes and we will be very appreciative. Or you can say no and we will remember.” As Eliott notes: “Another way to read that familiar frame? We can do this the easy way or the hard way.” Adding insult to injury, Trump later maligned NATO’s contributions supporting America’s war in Afghanistan, the only time the mutual defense clause of the NATO charter has ever been invoked (he later walked back his comments on the UK’s contribution, which included the loss of 457 dead British service members). And as is now well known, Denmark, the object of Trump’s ire, lost proportionally the highest number of soldiers killed in Afghanistan - fighting alongside US forces at the request of President Bush.
While Trump focused on American – or rather, his own -- grievances, Carney’s speech was the polar opposite, noting that the rules based order which has underpinned global security since 1945 is undergoing a “rupture.” Citing Thucydides’ famous axiom, Carney stated that “every day we're reminded that we live in an era of great power rivalry, that the rules based order is fading, that the strong can do what they can, and the weak must suffer what they must.”
Carney’s most important point was that the international system has never been entirely fair: middle powers like Canada and European nations have always had to cede some of their sovereignty to great powers like the US, which in turn provided stability and protection. This highlights one of the most important points that Trump and his acolytes have never understood: that the postwar liberal international order was designed by American policymakers to benefit the United States by creating a stable and secure global environment. In return the US got a whole spectrum of financial, economic, political and security benefits which more than offset the costs of supporting the system. As the journalist and historian Anne Applebaum has noted, Trump simply does not understand how the system has benefited the United States. He – and his advisers – think only in terms of grievance and leverage.
Interestingly, even China, which might seem to benefit from a rift between the US and its closest allies, has expressed unhappiness with US tactics. A Foreign Ministry spokesperson stated that “we urge the U.S. to stop using the so-called “China threat” as a pretext for itself to seek selfish gains.” Only Russia has expressed support for Trump’s position, equating it with Putin’s takeover of Crimea.
The costs of Trump’s volatile and transactional approach are becoming more apparent by the day. Though the President backed off his demands to take over Greenland, in no small part because the vast majority of the American public (over 87%) was completely opposed to a forceful takeover, the damage has most definitely been done. Europeans – and pretty much every other country in the world – have learned that they can stand up to Trump’s bullying and are building networks designed to bypass or minimize exposure to the US, economically, financially and intellectually. These shifts will undercut many of the systemic advantages that the US has built for itself over the past 80 years. Denmark and Sweden are selling off US treasury bonds (a move Treasury Secretary Bessent said “would defy logic,”), NATO allies are buying from each other rather than the US, and the EU is strengthening its economic ties to South America and Asia. Closer to home, Canada and China recently signed a trade deal, with Canada lowering the tariffs on Chinese electric vehicles from 100% to 6% and China decreasing tariffs on Canadian agricultural imports, a deal which will obviously undercut US farmers and automakers. [Speaking personally, on a trip to British Columbia in December, I noted that there was no American produce, meat or liquor in Canadian supermarkets and liquor stores].
America’s allies have learned a hard lesson. The US, once the architect of global stability, has become a dangerously unstable presence on the international scene. “I don’t know what will happen in the U.S.,” Danish Prime Minister Mette Frederiksen said during a recent Q & A session in Berlin. “I’m not responsible for what will happen in the U.S. I hope that they will stay in our alliance, but I don’t know what will happen.”