"The thugs that are protesting include many highly paid professional agitators and anarchists," (Donald Trump, on protests in Minneapolis, June 18, 2026)
“The surge is leaving Minnesota safer. I’ll say it again: It’s less of a sanctuary state for criminals.” (Tom Homan, Senior Official Performing the Duties of the Director of US Immigration and Customs Enforcement, Feb 12, 2026)
“We will help you [ICE] get to the airport. We will clear the road to get [you] to the airport. I will pack your damn bags if that’s what it takes.” (Minnesota Governor Tim Walz, Feb 12, 2026)
Throughout its history, the United States has frequently found itself in an uncomfortable state of equilibrium between its founding ideals and its current realities, between its aspirational moral beliefs and the need for order and stability. American history is replete with examples of individuals and organizations speaking up and taking actions in opposition to government policy – necessary because American history is also replete with efforts by federal, state and local governments to suppress dissent.
Such is the case in Minnesota. Following weeks of turmoil inflamed by assertive ICE and Border Patrol operations, the Trump Administration abruptly reduced its operations in Minneapolis. Although officials, including Acting ICE Director Homan, portrayed “Operation Metro Surge” as a success, the surge’s drawdown reflects an acknowledgment that the crackd was adversely affecting the administration’s reputation across the nation. Despite the removal of federal agents, Trump and his administration continue to project a stance of unwavering resolve, refraining from addressing controversies or apologizing for errors.
While many of Trump’s statements are performative, his Administration’s efforts to quell domestic protests are underpinned by something much more menacing: the White House’s Domestic Terrorism Directive, NSPM-7. The Directive authorizes preemptive law enforcement measures against citizens based on “perceived anti-Christian,” anti-capitalism,” and “anti-American” views. This is particularly dangerous because, as Ken Klipperstein notes, NSPM-7 can be used to treat political dissent as a form of domestic terrorism. When coupled with the aggressive use of ICE and Border Patrol in urban areas, the predictable result has been the unlawful incarceration and use of force against protestors (up to and including using live ammunition). Public figures who have opposed the Administration have been targeted by investigations from various agencies, including the Dept of Justice and the FBI.
As menacing as the Administration’s actions are, it is important to note that America’s history of resistance to authority began before the United States even was the United States. The Boston Tea Party, a milestone event which established a template for direct action protest that would echo throughout American history, was an iconic moment in the American founding narrative, representing defiance against perceived injustice and the willingness of ordinary people to challenge powerful institutions.
Protected by the Constitution’s First Amendment, the right to peaceful protest has had demonstrable effect throughout American history. Those protests started early: Objections to the 1798 Alien and Sedition Act, criminalizing the publishing of “false, scandalous and malicious writing” against the government helped elect Thomas Jefferson, who then allowed the Act to expire. From the 1830s, Abolitionists used rallies and speaking tours to demand an end to slavery, flooding Congress with petitions and engaging in acts of civil disobedience. These actions made slavery impossible to ignore politically, leading directly to the founding of the Republican Party and the election of Abraham Lincoln as President. Likewise, and beginning in 1848, the women’s suffrage movement organized conventions and parades, picketed the White House, went to prison and staged hunger strikes designed to force action on women’s voting rights. A suffragist parade in Washington DC in 1913 had 8000 marchers but over 500,000 spectators. When the spectators turned hostile, and police refused to protect the marchers, the resulting outrage generated national attention – and sympathy for the movement. Seven years later, in 1920, women’s suffrage became a reality with ratification of the 19th Amendment to the Constitution.
Perhaps the best known use of the power of public protest to generate political change was the civil rights movement. From the 1955 Montgomery Bus Boycott, touched off by Rosa Parks’ arrest, the sit-in movement, the Freedom Rides, Martin Luther King’s 1963 Birmingham campaign, and numerous other acts of protest, to mass rallies (including Martin Luther King's "I have a dream speech" delivered to 250,000 protestors on the Washington Mall), all contributed directly to the Civil Rights Act of 1964 and the Voting Rights Act of 1965. These protests were strategic: both deliberately provocative and very deliberately non-violent. Much as today, the violence largely came from representatives of the government rather than the protestors themselves, creating massive public pressure on the federal government to intervene.
Small changes can have enormous consequences. Looking at hundreds of campaigns over the last century, Harvard political scientist Erica Chenoweth found that nonviolent campaigns are twice as likely to achieve their goals as violent campaigns. And although the exact dynamics will depend on different circumstances, she has shown it takes around 3.5% of the population actively participating in protests to ensure real political change. The pattern is consistent: demonstrations rarely win immediate victories, but they make issues impossible to ignore, shift what is considered politically possible, and build movements that eventually force institutional change. They work by creating disruption, moral pressure, and political cost for maintaining the status quo. The data around President Trump’s hard crackdown on immigration – and the resulting civil unrest – seems to indicate that this threshold has already been met in America.
One of the best – and most politically courageous -- statements in modern American history was delivered by Republican Senator Margaret Chase Smith of Maine on June 1, 1950, at the height of McCarthy era paranoia in America. Her speech has particular relevance for today. Entitled the “Declaration of Conscience,” Chase Smith was the first prominent public official to push back on Senator Joseph McCarthy’s (R-Wisconsin) hitherto successful campaign of intolerance and red-baiting demagoguery. Reminding other members of the Senate of her strong Republican values, she stated that she did not “want to see the Republican Party ride to political victory on the ‘Four Horsemen of Calumny: Fear, Ignorance, Bigotry and Smear.’” Her declaration stated that all Americans share “the right to criticize, the right to hold unpopular beliefs, the right to protest and the right of independent thought.” Chase Smith’s declaration was eventually supported by six other Republican senators, and while it did not bring an immediate end to McCarthyism, it is now remembered as a landmark moment in defending America’s core values of free speech and the right of protest. It will be interesting to see if her act of political courage will be replicated by other Republicans in the coming days and months.