If you can keep it: What the midterm elections will really decide

Sources (15) ↓

“A republic, if you can keep it.” (attributed to Benjamin Franklin, when asked what the Constitution had created)

“If destruction be our lot, we must ourselves be its author and finisher. As a nation of freemen, we must live through all time, or die by suicide.” (Abraham Lincoln, Lyceum Address, 1838)

The United States is heading into one of its most consequential elections in decades, and the result will shape the politics and economics of this country, and much of the world, for years to come. Midterms are usually a referendum on the sitting president, and turnout is lower than in presidential years. This one will be an exception, and it needs to be, because the future shape of the Republic is on the line.

There are two ways to read this vote. The first, and the one most Americans see, is as a referendum on policy: what will the Trump administration do with its last two years if Republicans keep Congress? Expect more of the same. That means a Ukraine policy that tilts toward authoritarian Russia and away from pro-Western Ukraine, continued pressure on the alliances that have underpinned American security for eighty years, and a mismanaged war with Iran. It means tariffs, used both to raise revenue and to punish countries that offend the president (Canada, of all places), and an indulgent stance toward AI and data centers. It means cuts to the social safety net, health care included, in favor of business and the very wealthy; continued attacks on immigrants, documented and undocumented; an economy tilted back toward yesterday’s sources of power—coal, oil and gas—and away from green technology; and corruption that benefits the president’s family and friends.

As dangerous, regressive and downright foolish as many of these policies are, most of them are reversible. Apart from the provisions of the One Big Beautiful Bill Act, the bulk of Trump’s agenda rests on executive orders, and a future president can rescind those on their first day in office.

The greater danger, and the one that outlasts any administration, is structural: this election has become a referendum on the continuing effort to weaken American democracy itself. That effort includes voter intimidation and a steady campaign to erode public confidence in elections, paired with aggressive mid-decade gerrymandering. It includes a Justice Department that has shed its tradition of independence and become an instrument for supporting the president and punishing his opponents. And it includes pressure on the press, through lawsuits and through the removal of mainstream outlets from government spaces, including the White House and the Pentagon, in favor of pro-administration outlets.

Taken one at a time, each of these measures can seem minor. Taken together, they form a perceptible pattern that the scholars Steven Levitsky and Lucan Way have called competitive authoritarianism: elections still happen, but the referees lose their independence, the press is intimidated, the cost of opposition becomes too high, and the playing field tilts against challengers until the party in power becomes very hard to beat. Turkey and, until this spring, Hungary are the standard examples. Levitsky and Way, writing with Daniel Ziblatt, argue that the United States has slid toward this model during Trump’s second term, though they note that the slide can still be reversed.

This expansion of executive power has gone largely unchecked because a compliant Congress and a Supreme Court receptive to the “unitary executive” theory have allowed it. That theory, a conservative legal project since the Reagan years, reads Article II’s grant of “the executive Power” to a single president as giving him full control over everyone who wields it. A majority of the current Court has steadily embraced it, most dramatically in June’s Trump v. Slaughter, in which a 6–3 majority led by Chief Justice Roberts overruled Humphrey’s Executor, the 1935 precedent that allowed Congress to shield independent-agency heads from at-will removal. The long-term danger is that precedents set now will not expire with this president; they will be available to his successors, of either party.

All this means that the questions on the ballot on November 3 are profound. Will the United States remain a flawed democratic republic, or slide toward the competitive-authoritarian model? Will Congress keep ceding authority to the executive? Will interference in elections, including by the Justice Department, become standard practice? A Democratic victory, especially one that flips both chambers, would be a meaningful check, bringing what The Economist’s Shashank Joshi calls “subpoenas, shakeups and shutdowns.” He could also have added oversight, leverage over appropriations and a say in judicial and cabinet confirmations. But even a solid Democratic victory will have its limits. Democrats are unlikely to command the two-thirds majorities in both chambers needed to override presidential vetoes, so harder limits on presidential power may have to wait until 2029.

The United States has faced fateful elections before. In 1800, John Adams accepted defeat by Thomas Jefferson in the first peaceful transfer of power between rival parties. In 1860, Lincoln’s victory led eleven Southern states to secede and plunged the country into civil war. In 1932, Franklin Roosevelt’s election ushered in the New Deal and fundamentally altered Americans’ perception of the role of government in their lives. Perhaps more relevant to this election, the country has also had episodes of authoritarian overreach: the Alien and Sedition Acts of 1798, the Palmer Raids of 1919–20, the internment of Japanese Americans in World War II, and McCarthyism.

Democracy is under threat around the world, but the victories of Péter Magyar’s Tisza party in Hungary and Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva in Brazil—and the concessions of Viktor Orbán and, after first vowing to contest the result, Flávio Bolsonaro—offer some hope that the global tide may be turning. Democracy in America is not safe, but it is defensible, and it gets defended when people show up. And if early voting is any indication, they are indeed showing up: more than 39 million Americans had voted early by October 29, ahead of 2022’s pace, though some of that may simply reflect voters shifting away from Election Day. As Levitsky, Way and Ziblatt remind us, democracies today rarely fall in a single blow; they erode gradually, even as elections continue. Too often that erosion is accepted in exchange for promises of order, the very bargain Benjamin Franklin warned against in a 1755 reply from the Pennsylvania Assembly to its governor: “Those who would give up essential Liberty, to purchase a little temporary Safety, deserve neither Liberty nor Safety.”

Sources

Links go to the original publishers. Some require a subscription.

  1. In the run up to the election, the federal government is putting unprecedented pressure on democracy (NYU Brennan Center for Justice) Read article brennancenter.org
  2. Three issues defining the elections (Nolan D McCaskill/Reuters) Read article reuters.com
  3. William Galston - what history tells us about the upcoming midterm elections (William A Galston/Brookings) Read article brookings.edu
  4. Could the midterms make the world more dangerous? (Zanny Minton Beddoes, Edward Carr, David Rennie, Shashank Joshi/The Economist) - Could the midterms make the world more dangerous? Read article economist.com
  5. Trump’s “Never Go to Jail Card” (Thomas B. Edsall/NYTimes) Read article nytimes.com
  6. The midterm effect: what the 2026 election could mean for public policy (Brookings Institution in house experts) Read article brookings.edu
  7. Levitsky and Way: “The path to American authoritarianism: What comes after democratic breakdown” (Rick Hasan/Election Law Blog) Read article electionlawblog.org
  8. Supreme Court overrules Humphrey’s executor, vastly expands president’s removal authority – but preserves Federal Reserve independence (Allan S. Kaplinsky, John L Culhane, and Richard J. Andreano/Ballard Spahr LLP) Read article consumerfinancemonitor.com
  9. “Midterm Voters Show Up Early—and in Droves” (Josephine Walker/Axios) Read article axios.com
  10. “Millions of Americans Have Already Cast Their Votes for the Midterms, Data Shows,” (Saige Miller and A. Martinez/NPR) Read article npr.org
  11. Lincoln’s election affected the US most, survey shows (McConnell Center, University of Louisville) Read article news.louisville.edu
  12. The American presidency: pivotal elections (LBJ Presidential Library) Read article news.louisville.edu
  13. Five midterm elections that changed America () Read article history.com
  14. Brazil’s left wing president elected to a fourth term (Catherine Osborne/NPR) Read article npr.org
  15. Peter Magyar wins Hungary election, unseating Viktor Orban after 15 years (Al Jazeera staff) Read article aljazeera.com

All newsletters